Managerial Control
Decision-making & Implementation
From simple relevant costs and benefits analyses to detailed Monte Carlo simulations and stochastic, dynamic programs, we can help you think more clearly about business issues and problems.
For example, if a series of seemingly optimal decisions have not turned-out as anticipated, it could be simply bad luck, or it could be the inaccurate identification and specification of the problem. That means you might be including irrelevant factors or excluding relevant ones in your decisions. Or, could mean that you made a sound decision but it was poorly implemented. The lack of proper controls, including poorly-designed incentive schemes, can doom the best intentions of men and firms.
We can’t change your luck, but we can (1) help protect against bad luck and (2) help with almost any control–related issue or problem.
What do we mean by control?
We use the word ‘control’ a lot because control involves determining and implementing policies, procedures and actions to accomplish one’s goals. It’s what you are trying to do everyday when you manage and lead your firm or organization; so, it involves all types of decisions – both short-term and long-term, including the choice of strategies and investments, ways of organizing functions as well as tactics and modes of operating.
We don’t want it to sound too general, because we help solve very specific problems, but with a broad framework, we’re often able to show connections and relationships (and causes) of problems that would otherwise stay hidden (and doom your prospective chances of success).
Control also involves the performance measurement of business units and individuals, and generation of feedback (reports) to adapt policies and plans to increase the likelihood that goals are met in the future. Thus, control involves the optimal design and implementation of information systems, including financial information and/or accounting systems.
We excel at being able to determine the behavior implications of information system design, including how to subtlety influence employees by the information you present to them.
Ask a typical IT consultant about the behavioral implications of information system design, and most likely, you’ll get a blank stare that says, “what do management information systems have to do with people?” Our answer: just about everything.
Our control practice is very broad and encompasses almost all aspects of finance, accounting, and strategy. (We taught and consulted on all of those topics.) It seems to continually expand into new areas.
It includes decision making; the design of control, incentive, and performance management and measurement systems; the design of cost and information systems, and the determination and estimation of relevant costs for short– and long-term decisions. Here are a few examples:
- The linkage of strategies, organizational structure, and control, including optimal performance measurement. We often ask: do you want information from your subordinates or effort? Generally, it’s difficult or infeasible to get both. More precisely, it’s difficult to get both in an efficient (profit-maximizing) way, i.e., you can’t get both cheaply!
- The development of cost reporting systems that support the organization’s goals and strategies. This is much more interesting and important than many managers think. Don’t leave it to the accountants to determine what information you need for your decisions.
- The determination of cost behavior and the identification of relevant costs for all types of organizational decisions. We have noticed that many projects that start elsewhere end here with the same basic issue: determining what’s relevant and what is not. For example, one firm wanted a new activity-based costing system to help identify additional relevant costs. We explained that such a system would be very expensive. It would be much more detailed, but it would not provide any new information (relevant costs) for any operating decision that could not be estimated for the existing system. (Instead, we showed them how to extract available information from the existing system and thereby save a lot of money.)
